A person is ‘laconic’ if they use very few words, especially with the confrontational terseness of of unintimidated Spartans. A way of speaking counts as a ‘drawl’ if it is slow and elongated, especially when it comes to vowels. Clearly these words are pointing in different directions: one naturally thinks of a laconic speaker as employing clipped syllables, not wasting their breath on the enemy.
And yet “laconic drawl” appears to be a collocation: I found 72 results in Google Scholar, presumably in edited writing. One might conclude that the writers are deliberately trading in paradox. Maybe they’re talking about an amusing case in which a laconic speaker takes a few words and drawlingly stretches them out to the length of a normal sentence. But the examples don’t seem to fit:
- Biting into one of the 12-year-old biscuits, KerryJayne announced in her laconic drawl, “Poor John Darby, they gave the bastard stale biscuits.” [This doesn’t seem laconic at all.]
- Mr Robin Ramsay's face, now deadpan as a comedian's, now mobile and droll; his voice, with a hundred subtle modulations of its laconic drawl, were alike perfect... [This doesn’t seem to have anything to do with laconic speech.]
- Famous for his slow, laconic drawl he was quick to take on the mantle of Territory jingoism. [Here we get whiplash, as we go from ‘slow’ to ‘laconic’ and back to ‘drawl’.]
- When Snoop half-sings, in his laconic drawl, the mantra “I don’t love them hoes,” the tonal semantics do not overtly suggest a testy disavowal or fear of female sexuality. [Five may be a small number of words, but there’s obviously nothing the slightest bit laconic about Snoop Dogg’s rapping.]
Can anyone explain what’s going on here? Thanks!
EDIT: I think I’m being asked to consult a dictionary. I’ll use the OED and Merriam-Webster:
laconic (OED): 1.a. (With capital initial.) Of or pertaining to Laconia or its inhabitants, made or written in Laconia; Lacedæmonian, Spartan. Now rare. 1.b. Characteristic of the Laconians; Spartan-like. 2. Following the Laconian manner, esp. in speech and writing; brief, concise, sententious. Of persons: Affecting a brief style of speech.
laconic (M-W): using or involving the use of a minimum of words: concise to the point of seeming rude or mysterious
drawl (OED): 1. The action or an act of drawling; esp. a way of speaking slowly using prolonged vowel sounds. Now often associated with accents of the American South. 2. Slow loitering pace. rare.
drawl (M-W): a drawling manner of speaking [based on the following verb meanings: (intr.) to speak slowly with vowels greatly prolonged, (tr.) to utter in a slow lengthened tone
I think it’s clear that these dictionary entries do not resolve the question, but rather make the question more pressing.